Patents, pills, poverty and pandemic: the ethical issues

Brown, Walter (2003) Patents, pills, poverty and pandemic: the ethical issues. Masters thesis, Rhodes University.




This thesis argues that corporations qua corporations are moral agents sui generis and hence capable of being held morally responsible. I argue that corporations qua corporations are responsible for the actual and foreseen consequences of their actions. I analyse normative theories and the different proscriptive responsibilities they place on moral agents and hence corporations. I examine Kantianism, utilitarianism and virtue ethics. I argue for a unique normative ethical theory that incorporates reasoning from all three of the normative theories. I argue for a broad range of reasons to factor into deciding whether an act is ethical or not. One of the claims of this thesis is that ethical theories must incorporate an agent’s motivation, intention and character traits as relevant to deciding on whether an action is ethical or not. My thesis argues for an indispensable role for the virtues while at the same time incorporating impartial beneficence and universal rationality from utilitarianism and Kantianism. This position I, following the literature, refer to as moderate virtue theory. Having established corporate qua corporate responsibility I question the pharmaceutical corporation’s practice of patenting life saving medication during a state of pandemic in poor countries. The moderate virtue theory position prioritises contexts and the actual human condition and criticises normative theories that attempt to give universal, abstracted answers to ethical problems. It is for this reason and the current (2003) HIV/AIDS pandemic that I focus on a particular context. I examine the practice of patenting life saving medication within South Africa and argue, applying moderate virtue theory, that this act cannot be justified. I argue that a pharmaceutical corporation that patents life saving medication in South Africa cannot justify that action and thus is morally responsible for that action. I also argue that corporations patenting HIV/AIDS medication in South Africa have unethical motivations and intentions.

Item Type:Thesis (Masters)
Additional Information:A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in the department of Philosophy
Uncontrolled Keywords:virtue ethics, patents, poverty, HIV/AIDS pandemic, medication, South Africa
Subjects:Y Unknown > Subjects to be assigned
Divisions:Faculty > Faculty of Humanities > Philosophy
ID Code:142
Deposited By: Rhodes Library Archive Administrator
Deposited On:09 Sep 2005
Last Modified:06 Jan 2012 16:22
624 full-text download(s) since 09 Sep 2005
77 full-text download(s) in the past 12 months
More statistics...

Repository Staff Only: item control page